Asymptomatic transmission – The claim healthy people can spread infections

All measures, whether mandatory masks, lockdowns, or quarantine measures, are based on the assumption that even healthy people, falsely called „asymptomatically ill“ by mass media, can infect other healthy people. Not only has this not been proven to date, it is classified as „very rare“ even by the WHO. There are very few studies, but they are all based only on the evaluation of reporting data, which in turn are the result of the PCR test, which is anything but reliable. There is no REAL subject study, only estimates, extrapolations and guesses. And even there, statisticians disagree. A potential danger from virus carriers without symptoms has not been proven so far.

The research evidence is very lacking so far, although there are a few studies suggesting that presymptomatic or asymptomatic carrier may cause COVID-19 transmission. Nearly half of the literature is in the state of preprint without peer review. The question of „the degree to which presymptomatic or asymptomatic infections can transmit“ is not fully understood. (PubMed, medical database 2020/04)

The screening of the 9,865,404 participants without a history of COVID-19 found no newly confirmed COVID-19 cases, and identified 300 asymptomatic positive cases with a detection rate of 0.303 (95% CI 0.270–0.339)/10,000. (…) A total of 1174 close contacts of the asymptomatic positive cases were traced, and they all tested negative for the COVID-19. (Wuhan-Study 2020)

On the question of „asymptomatic transmission“, it can currently be said that, according to the WHO, true asymptomatic transmission still seems to be rare (…), whereas pre-symptomatic transmission in the days before the first symptoms (…) is very likely and may explain the rapid spread of the virus. Pre-symptomatic transmission is also known from influenza, but there the incubation period is much shorter, so this should be somewhat less relevant. (SWPRS)

Viral culture studies suggest that people with SARS-CoV-2 can become infectious one to two days before the onset of symptoms and continue to be infectious up to seven days thereafter; viable virus is relatively short lived. Symptomatic and presymptomatic transmission have a greater role in the spread of SARS-CoV-2 than truly asymptomatic transmission. (BMJ, global healthcare knowledge provider)

It is not true that asymptomatic people can pass on Covid-19, so, the severe disease (…). The viral load is much too small and that is known. That’s what I’m criticizing. The statement that asymptomatic people can spread the virus is based on model calculations. All model calculations. And those kinds of model calculations have never been correct. All these apocalyptic predictions were based on the same wrong computer calculations. (Prof. Sucharit Bhakdi, infectious epidemiologist)

We found significantly higher secondary attack rates from symptomatic index cases than asymptomatic or presymptomatic index cases, although less data were available on the latter. The lack of substantial transmission from observed asymptomatic index cases is notable. However, presymptomatic transmission does occur, with some studies reporting the timing of peak infectiousness at approximately the period of symptom onset. (JAMA network)

I do not agree with some of the statements in the following video and have also marked these passages, or stated my counter-position to them. Nevertheless, I think it is right and important in the context of an open debate to leave the statements as they are, but to comment on them if necessary.

Transcription of the World Doctors Alliance film „Is Asymptomatic Transmission Fake News?“.

Who is the World Doctors Alliance? Here is the disclaimer of their website (

We are an independent non-profit alliance of doctors, nurses, healthcare professionals and staff around the world who have united in the wake of the Covid-19 response chapter to share experiences with a view to ending all lockdowns and related damaging measures and to re-establish universal health determinance of psychological and physical wellbeing for all humanity.

Prof. Sucharit Bhakdi (GER)
Journalist: So we’ve been told there are these asymptomatic carriers and then children can be these super spreaders and all this. Is that accurate at all?

Prof. Sucharit Bhakdi, specialist in microbiology and infectious disease epidemiology

Bhakdi: It is complete nonsense. It’s never been shown. It’s a claim. It’s a claim that has been spread as a fact and this I consider criminal. The idea of asymptomatic carrier, spreading the disease Covid-19 which is the pneumonia not a cough but the pneumonia Covid-19 is untrue. And it is backed by zero data. There is not a single case in the world documented. So in fact the whole business is a fake.

Journalist: And that’s the basis of the masks, of a lot of these measures isn’t it?

Bhakdi: Yes, this is the, you know, inhuman part of it. Forcing people to wear masks because of no reason. Taking away their rights as humans without reason.

Michael McNamara (Covid-19 Committe) vs. Dr. John Cuddihy (WHO):
Michael McNamara: Somebody who is asymptomatic, shows no symptoms whatsoever of covid and they have a heart attack and are brought to hospital and they’re tested and it is found they have covid and they die soon thereafter but this is somebody who demonstrated no symptoms whatsoever, are they recorded as a covid death or not? If they have tested positive for covid but ultimately came to hospital because they’ve had a heart attack or a stroke or fallen off the roof of a building or something like that?

Dr. John Cuddihy: We adhere to the World Health Organisation case definition in terms of their recording and reporting of deaths. SO in the situation that you described where someone has a positive covid test it is a death in a confirmed covid case. But such a case would be subject to a coroner’s report as well and as part of the ongoing validation of the data in our surveillance system. We would take additional details in relation to such a case.

Michael McNamara: But a corona’s report, sorry I’m trying to be very brief, obviously a corona’s report takes a very long time to make it’s way through the system. So if for now they are recorded as a covid death, but it may be that they are taken off that list at a later date. Is that what you’re saying?

Dr. John Cuddihy: That’s it exactly.

Michael McNamara: If somebody is admitted to hospital, they’re asymptomatic with a broken leg for example and require hospitalisation and they’re tested and they ae asymptomatic but test positive. Are they included among the statistics of those in hospital with covid?

Dr. John Cuddihy: They are included in the surveillance statistics yep.

Michael McNamara: And they are statistics that are relayed to the daily press conferences?

Dr. John Cuddihy: Yes, that’s right.

Michael McNamara, politician (UK)

Dr. Andrew Kaufman M.D. (US):
Hello. I’m Dr. Andrew Kaufman M.D. I’m a board certified general and forensic psychiatrist in the state of New York in the United States. I’m here to tell you that there is no asymptomatic spread of disease. We have grown up our entire lives and never once have we ever worried about catching any illness from other healthy people. We’ve never taken any special precautions around other healthy people. And whenever there has been a need for a quarantine in the context of a dangerous inefctious disease, the people quarantined have always been people who were ill with the disease. In othe wods they had symptoms and were very sick. The current situation is completely unprecedented and further there is no scientific evidence that shows that oeple without symptoms who are healthy are capable of transmitting this illness.

There have been several studies looking at populations of people who have had a positive PCR test and following around everyone they made contact with. In one study they looked at several thousand people, that were in contact with individuals who had a positive test yet did not have any symptoms. IN all these studies there were no evidence that these people who were healthy and had a positive PCR test spread any illness to anyone. The only evidence that has ever been presented is based only on theoretical computer models but not on real world studies. Therefore there is no scientific basis for any policies separating healthy pople from other healthy people. That includes social distancing and social isolation, lockdowns and mask wearing. None of these have any base in evicence because healthy people don’t spread disease to other healthy people.

Dr. Andrew Kaufman MD, forensic psychiatrist

Dr. Zac Cox (UK):
Hello. I’m Zac Cox. I’m a holistic dentist and a homeopath. I’m a founder member of the World Doctor’s Alliance. Alliance put together to enable the other side of the argument to be heard. Doctors are being censored left right and centre. Doctors are being arrested. Doctors are having their licence removed, merely for questioning what is going on. If we are to accept this as a society then we are accepting tyranny. Censorship of any kind is abhorrent in a free world. One of the biggest lies we are being told at the moment is asymptomatic spread. Everybody is terrified of their fellow man. They’re scared to hug granny. Ironic really when it was the governments themselves that sent infected people into the care homes from hospitals and thereby infected and spread covid to the care homes and killed tens of thousands of people. It is the government who are directly responsible for that. So its a bit rich when Matt Hancock comes on TV and tells you not to hug granny. Its an outrage.

They are lying, just like Tony Blair lied with his weapons of mass destruction. The reality is, people who spread infections have symptoms. You have to be symptomatic in order to spread a respiratory infection. SO, let’s all get back to normal. Proper normal. No restrictions, no masks. Businesses open, no social distances, schools open, universities open, democracy restored. Time to see the truth. Why would so many doctors speak out and risk their licences? Just think about that. What have we got to gain? Nothing. Abolutely nothing. We’re just trying to tell you the truth. The covid pandemic was not even the worst year for deaths. When you factor in population growth and age. In fact, 2020 was 9th in the last 20 years.

Dr. Zac Cox, holistic dentist and homeopath

Dr. Anna Forbes (UK):
Hello my name is Dr. Anna Forbes. I’m an integrative medical doctor and functional medicine doctor in London UK. We ar currently locking the world down, shutting schools, cancelling important medical appointments. We’re seeing massive increase in rates of domestic abuse. We’re seeing dramatic increases in mental health problems and suicides and excess deaths because of delayed treatments and delayed diagnoses for serious disease and a lot of this is based on the concept of asymptomatic spread. So that means transmitting the virus and disease even if you don’t have any symptoms. And that is what we’re basing a lot of things on. I would like to say that this has never been done before in history. We are relying on pretty inaccurate tests to be able to diagnose this disease and there is a gross misrepresentation of the data with regards to cases those with infections an deaths, covid deaths, and this is seriously concerning and i would vehemently argue that what we are currently doing is far more damaging than the virus itself.

People need to stop being scared of healthy people. People who are not displaying signs and symptoms of infectious disease. We know naturally and innately when someone has an infectious disease, particularly when we see it all over the place and we see the very damaging effects from it, which is not the case here, people re not seeing regularly people very very unwell all over the place and dying. You know if you speak to peopla their normal experience is not that. Yes they’re seeing it in the news, they’re hearing the cases etc. but it’s not their day to day experience of seeing this and that’s when people normally will isolate and keep away from each other in those circumstances. But the situation we’ve arrived at now with people being scared of being close to people who are completely healthy, it really beggars belief. It has become much more of a problem than the problem we are trying so sort out. So I would really urge to get back in touch with their common sense, to get back in touch with their sense of humaity.

Dr. Anna Forbes, integrative medical doctor and functional medicine doctor

Dr. Johan Denis (B):
My name is Dr. Johan Denis from Belgium. The coronavirus is in terms of harmfulness, mortality and transmissibility comparable to a seasonal flu. All numbers are very clear on that. There are no data supporting asymptomatic spread. Healthy people cannot transmit a virus to someone else. Only sick people can. So we don’t have to fear each other. Kids can play as they used to and embrace their grandparents. They are no danger to them. There is no need to be afraid of your healthy fellow men. It’s time to hug and shake hands again. Throw your masks away. Social distancing is not neccessary. Lockdowns are useless, there is no medical evidence for them. Quarantine is only for sick people as we have done for centuries. Healthy people can resume their lives.

We have been lied to. The whole pandemic is based on the PCR test, the nose swab. Without the test we wouldn’t know the difference with a normal flu year. This PCR test is a medical fraud that makes from healthy people so called infected cases while they are feeling fine. All the numbers you hear on your television are based on this fraud. It’s fake. There is nothing to fear. You have been fooled. Court cases are running and a retraction of the scientific paper supporting this fraudulant PCR test has been laid down. Inform yourself well. Go to our website where everything is explained. Look also at the documentary „the new normal“ on BLckBx.TV and you will see the whole picture. I bless you all.

Dr. Johan Denis, physician and surgeon

Dr. Vernon Coleman (UK):
My name is Vernon Coleman. I am a qualified doctor and I practiced as a GP principal for 10 years befor becoming a professional author. I believe covid-19 is the greatest hoax in history. I don’t mean the the infection is a hoax. It’s as real as the flu. It’s replaced. The flu that can kill 650.000 people worldwide in six month. The hoax lies in the deceits and misrepresentations that have marked this exercise in fear and have characterized covid-19 since March 2020 when the U.K. Government was officially advised that covid-19 was in the same category as the flu. Around the world, politicians and advisors built absurd predictions to terrify populations everywhere. They intruduced pointless and destructive social distancing. They introduced lockdowns and closed hospital departments, knowing that this would turn cancer and heart patients into second class citizens and kill far more people than the coronavirus.

Elderly people in care homes were murdered.

(Murdered? Evidence?)

Politicians corrupted the media with promises of bottomless advertising budgets. Throughout it all they lied about the science, picking and chossing the bits of evidence they found most useful. The WHO said lockdowns were bad but they went ahead anyway. The WHO said PCR tests were potentially misleading but governments ignored that inconvenient truth and continued to manipulate a system designed to produce more false positives than real positives. When the WHO ignored the evidence that masks do more harm than good and recommended that they be worn, politicians decided people should wear masks all day long. The masks will result in thousands deaths from bacterial pneumonia. And they lied about how covid-19 ca be transmitted. At the beginning they told us it spread by coughing and sneezing, hence social distancing, ignoring the science again because a cough can send droplets 20 to 30 feet.

They need to ramp up the fear to sell their dangerous and experimental vaccine. Incidentally the WHO says ther’s no guarantee the vaccine stops you getting covid or stops you transmitting it if you do. Research in China, which involved just under 10 million people found that asymptomatic spread of covid does not occur. Throughout it all, politicians and advisors have refused to debate and have suppressed the truth. I first described the coronavirus scare as a hoax on March 18th 2020. The word hoax is now used widely but bacl then I toyed with a different word… Fraud. That the word I should have used, because that’s what it is. It’s about power and money. A huge money making fraud which involves destroying economies everywhere. Political leaders and their scientific advisors are going to go prison, which is where they belong.

Dr. Vernon Coleman, doctor and GP principal

Dr. Barre Lando (US):
Hi. My name is Dr. Barre Paul Lando. I’m an integated healthcare practioner with 40 lus years clinical experience in Bio-terrain medicine in the US. I have both conventional and alternative certifications as a primary healthcare provider. I’d like to ask you a few questions:

Have you ever saught medical help because you felt fine?
Have you ever avoided perfectly healthy people for fear of illness transmission?
If not, why would you change this very rational behaviour now?

Consider the following facts well documented by many doctors worldwide, working outside of the present political medical sector that is clearly under the control of vested interest. SARS-CoV-2 has not been proven to exist*. Actual isolation means the virus exists. Inability to isolate it means is no proof the virus exists. It has not been isolated. If they haven’t isolated the virus, how can they make the vaccine?

This is’nt true. The Sars-Cov2-Virus is isolated since March 2020
„The first US patient was diagnosed by the State of Washington and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on January 20, 2020. We isolated virus from nasopharyngeal and oropharyngeal specimens, and characterized the viral sequence, replication properties, and cell culture tropism.“

(continued with Dr. vernon Coleman)
Junk medical science uses animal models as proof of infection. Lab animals, typically mice, are not human. And since ther’s no such thing as an isolated virus, what are they injecting into animals to provoke sickness? This practice is a tragic farce. So what are people dying of? Hospitals and doctors are presently subsidised to label symptoms in death based on proven flawed covid testing procedures as covid caused regardless of pre-existing conditions. Trauma or other causative circumstances.

Human health is very much related to our ability to engage in intimate interaction with members of our own species. Psychological isolation through mask wearing. Social distancing greatly affects that part of our brain, the amygdala and hippocampus that is stimulated by healthy social interaction and is impeded by isolating ourselves from others. Since this critical neurological centres also produce neuron stem cells, we are actually interfering with the normal maintenance repair of our central nervous system through isolation practices. The only real virus is fear and it has been very effectively weaponised against us. The only real antedote is truth. So let me ask you one final question.

Do you choose to believe politicians, globalists, and doctors with clearly vested monetary interests and desire for greater control over the mass of humaity?

Or does it make more sense to trust independent medical experts and scientists, who point out the obvious fallacies in this clearly false flag pandemic that any one of you can validate through independent research?

Please people, don’t let them divide us any longer. Don’t enable these crimes against humaity through compliance. And for God’s sake, don’t let them rob you of your humanity.

Dr. Barre Paul Lando, integated healthcare practioner

What did the World Health Organisation say?

Dr. Maria Van Kerkove:
They’re following asymptomatic cases. They’re following contacts and they’re not finding secondary transmission onward. It’s VERY RARE.

Dr. Maria Van Kerkhove, WHO

The question of asymptomatic infection is the crucial one. Even if everything so far indicates that people without symptoms cannot infect others, as things stand at present, presymptomatic people, i.e. people with mild symptoms, can. But where is the border? Some people are pre-symptomatic, but feel healthy and would always say that they don’t have any symptoms.

As long as no authoritative study proves that symptomless people are not contagious, the responsibility remains with each individual to test in case, even of mild symptoms. I think it is nonsense for healthy people to test themselves. As Prof. Sucharit Bhakdi said in agreement with other immunologists, symptomless people have too low a viral load to be able to infect others. As the December 2020 report „Household Transmission of SARS-CoV-2“ shows, by far the greatest risk of infection is at home. But that’s exactly where the lockdowns and curfews are corralling people!

Sources under the video on Bitchute:

Asymptomatic transmission study:

WDA on Telegram:

Information and more presented in this video can be sourced from the following websites:

The Great Barrington Declaration